Viewport width =
September 24, 2007 | by  | in Opinion | [ssba]

Answer to Professor Pomo

All religion is evil, and to the extent that its adherents recognise its fabrications for what they are and go on adhering to them, its adherents are evil too. That’s by no means all of them—many just muddle on in unquestioning, custom-based acquiescence to what they’ve been brought up in. Even the latter group, however, may be faulted precisely for being “unquestioning”—not subjecting what they’ve been indoctrinated with to critical examination.

Silent Muslims may be faulted for mindlessly persisting with the nonsense that is Islam, and they may—nay, should—be lambasted for their silence in the face of the atrocities perpetrated by those who take their Koran literally, those whom I call “Islamo-Fascists.”

Now, at no point have I said, “All Muslims are Islamo-Fascists” as claimed by Professor Morris in his Counterpoint article (Sept 10). That claim is false—about what I’d expect from someone who makes a taxpayer-funded living teaching about untruth systems. I have called for death to Islamo-Fascism since it has called for death to us; I have called Islam a “stupid, stinking superstition”, because it is.

But at no point have I equated the two. As it happens, I believe that to be a true Muslim one must be a fascist, just as I believe that to be a true Christian one must be a fascist, but I note thankfully that many Muslims and Christians are not “true”.

They are, however, ominously silent.

On air during Islam Awareness Week I invited all Muslims to “renounce and denounce Jihad, fatwa and Sharia Law; commit to respecting the rights of those of other faiths, or no faith, to our beliefs; join with me and every other freedom-lover in a chorus of, ‘I disagree with what you say but defend to the death your right to say it.’” No Muslim responded. I repeat the invitation here. As long as Muslims are not going to demand anything of me at scimitar-point, I’m more than willing to leave them alone to believe their rubbish.

I’ll still call it rubbish, though. And that is what anti-freedom academics like Morris can’t hack. When he says freedom of the press “entails a duty to be informed and responsible, not a licence to distort and misrepresent”, what he really means is that it entails an obligation to agree with and purvey his own mystic-statist worldview. At least, I’m assuming this since he failed to specify just how I was misinformed and irresponsible in my remarks about Islam, just as he failed to specify how Ayaan Hirsi was in hers (funny how all respondents have ignored her!).

Prof. Morris observes that “we do live in a world that is increasingly religiously diverse and we do need to seriously think how we might live together in non-violent ways.” In a world where superstition is resurgent (“increasingly religiously diverse”), the ones who need to do some thinking about peaceful co-existence, I would have thought, are the superstitious. Would the good professor care to direct his remarks to the President of Iran, who has vowed to wipe Israel off the map?

(And while he’s about it, would he care to offer any observations on the “moral crackdown” going on in Iran right now whereby tens of thousand of women have been warned over slack dress, 3000 “immoral” cafes and billiard halls have been shut down and 27,000 illegal satellite receivers have been confiscated?) Would he care to advise Osama bin Laden about “how we might live together in non-violent ways,” or does Osama’s latest anti-capitalist diatribe resonate too well with him? Would he care to rebuke al Qaeda in Iraq for the car-bombings and beheadings or would he consider such a reprimand “offensive” to Muslims? Ditto, any remonstration with the London demonstrators re their placards calling for death to freedom of speech, a new holocaust against Jews, etc.?

Professor Morris affects to applaud my call for rationality and decency, but says it can’t be taken seriously from me because of my recommending “robust sodomy” of Muslims as they bend towards Mecca. What can’t be taken seriously is that he would take that seriously. Such is the paucity of his case, it would seem, that he must repair to treating piss-taking as meant literally when he knows full well it wasn’t.

Morris concludes by recommending “a course in Islam or joining a local interfaith group and talking to Muslims about what they actually believe and do.”

I can save folk the time. All Muslims believe nonsense. Some Muslims do terror as well.


About the Author ()

Comments (9)

Trackback URL / Comments RSS Feed

  1. Mario Lanza says:

    Perigo, you are a ridiculous and despicable moron. You are an idiot of the most dangerous sort. Why are you writing for Salient? I expect it is the only source which is still silly enough to carry your inflammatory rantings.

  2. Nur says:

    I stopped reading Salient since my first year here because of the rubbish writers such as you write, but this has gone beyond limits. It is so disappointing to see the money that we pay for Salient (perhaps some to you) are used in turn to insult us – and yes I am a Muslim.

    When people talk of Islam, they always think of the Arabs, the middle east and the terrorists that are so often associated with the religion. In case you haven’t notice, there is actually an increasing number of Asian Muslims in Vic who have never even been to the middle east. And of course we are vehemently against terrorism, as much as we are against this behaviour of publicly offending and insulting others. On no grounds should you show such gross disrespect for Islam, or any religion for that matter.

    When you’re telling Muslims what we believe is just a ‘stupid,stinking superstition’ and ‘nonsense’, its like telling BILLIONS of Muslims believers worldwide that they’re stupid. I pity you for your lost soul, I bet you’re still searching the purpose of life hence you create such stir so that people pay attention to you.

    Our role as Muslims to correct misunderstandings and to deter such disrespect has been increasingly challenging. I hope this will make you happy – we will seek advice from uni authority to take action against you,and we will try bringing this issue up to FIANZ, in view of closing the understanding gap between Muslims and non-Muslims. However, perhaps much to your disappointment we will continue to bend to Allah, because we have faith. But I’m sure you don’t.

  3. Mario Lanza says:

    salaam alaikum Nur. Thanks for your comments, very well said. I’d be interested in suporting any action you might take against Lindsady Perigo

  4. Death to Fascist Faggots says:

    Ah Lindsay you old pillow biter, so you’re still desperately trying to upset people for a little attention. Why not try the Jews on for size you hateful little poof.
    Vic students are going to get bored of you quickly. Maybe you’d have better luck cruising the botanical gardens.

  5. mike says:

    Ah well, perigo, not long to go till your fun in the sunshine ends. No one, but the sad A-Team agrees with your shit. You can get your mates in Auckland to write about how cool you are, but Salient ends its run for this year in a couple weeks. Don’t think you will get a chance to write for it next year. Stick to your blog and sad little radio show. Bye bye

  6. Mario Lanza says:

    Haha – the A-Team. I support his right to be a homosexual, but don’t like the fact that he is an ill-informed loudmouth twat. Perhaps if Lindsay were allowed to wrap his venomous lips around the luncheon meat truncheon of a young A-Teamer (or two) he might be quiet for awhile.

  7. Richard Wiig says:

    Hur said: “On no grounds should you show such gross disrespect for Islam, or any religion for that matter.”

    Hur, who disrespects Islam the most. Osama Bin Laden, or Lindsay Perigo?

  8. perianwyr says:

    This post is great, it’s the best post

  9. Glenn Jameson says:

    Hello, Hur…? Didn’t answer a very good question…

    While you’re at it, perhaps you would care to comment on certain peace and loving aspects of Islam, like female circumcision, stonings for homos, adulterers and heretics, your prophet’s well documented paedophilia and the modern day disciples who perpetuate this disgusting habit to justify their great teacher’s pernicious predilections, the Jihad against the West and the blowing up innocents in the name of Allah, etc… etc… etc…

Recent posts

  1. VUW Halls Hiking Fees By 50–80% Next Year
  2. The Stats on Gender Disparities at VUW
  3. Issue 25 – Legacy
  4. Canta Wins Bid for Editorial Independence
  5. RA Speaks Out About Victoria University Hall Death
  6. VUW Hall Death: What We Know So Far
  8. New Normal
  9. Come In, The Door’s Open.
  10. Love in the Time of Face Tattoos

Editor's Pick

Uncomfortable places: skin.

:   Where are you from?  My list was always ready: England, Ireland, Scotland, Wales, puppy dogs’ tails, a little Spanish, maybe German, and—almost as an afterthought—half Samoan. An unwanted fraction.   But you don’t seem like a Samoan. I thought you were [inser

Do you know how to read? Sign up to our Newsletter!

* indicates required